GAPS in migrant return policies

GAPs aims to examine the disconnects and discrepancies between expectations of return policies and their actual outcomes by decentring the dominant, one-sided understanding of ‘return policy-making’. The project examines the shortcomings of the European Union return governance, analyses enablers of and barriers to international cooperation and explores the perspectives of migrants themselves to understand their knowledge, aspirations and experiences with return policies.

 

The GAPs project focuses on return gaps in three return systems between EU countries and countries of transit or origin, spanning the wider Middle East (including Afghanistan), Africa (northern and western), and eastern Europe. The project treats ‘gaps’ as a heuristic that allows us to zoom in on three dimensions: 

  • governance
  • international cooperation
  • migrants’ agency.

The project combines a decentring approach with three innovative concepts to analyse governance fissures, understand how relations among EU member states and third countries hinder cooperation on returns, and use a socio-spatial and temporal lens to understand migrant 
agency. The project involves multi-disciplinary, qualitative, and quantitative comparative research, 
with wide-ranging impacts such as the creation of an interactive data repository on returns, a return cooperation index, policy briefs and stakeholder expert panels. 

GAPs also aims to examine the agency of migrants and the autonomy of migration processes that influence and are influenced by governance and cooperation. It will also seek to co-create alternative pathways and models for existing return policies, practices and cooperation that would contribute to the interplay between policy and science.

Find more information on the GAPS website

Publications

Report

Saleh, L.

Public Attitudes towards Return Migration: Analysis of five EU member states

GAPs (2025)

Open
Other

Vollmer, R., Mielke, K., & Wolf, D.

Kontroversen um Rückführungen: Ein Plädoyer für eine transparente, wissensbasierte und inklu-sive Migrationspolitik

GAPs (2025)

Open
Report

Barthoma, S., Şahin-Mencütek, Z., & Mielke, K.

Return Programmes and Diaspora/Migrant Organizations: Projections and Realities

GAPs (2025)

Open
Journal article

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., & Triandafyllidou, A.

Coerced return: formal policies, informal practices and migrants’ navigation

Sussex Centre for Migration Research , Brighton (2024)

Open
Other

Vollmer, R.

Nomination of “Remigration” as Un-word of the year

(2024)

Open
Report

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., & Yilmaz-Elmas, F.

GAPs Data Repository on Return: Guideline, Data Samples and Codebook

BICC , Bonn (2024)

Open
Report

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., Mielke, K., & Wolf, D.

Legal and Policy Infrastructures of Returns in Germany

GAPs , Bonn (2024)

Open
Report

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., Triandafyllidou, A., Barthoma, S., Nimer, M., Rottman, S., Ozturk, N., & Istaiteyeh, R.

Framework paper on the concepts and typologies on returns - combined with four conceptual notes

(2023)

Open
Other

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., & Kurt, M.

The politicization of refugees in Turkey’s elections is not yet over with local elections on the way...

(2023)

Open
Other

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., & Barthoma, S.

No place for refuge and no place for (eventual) return of Palestinians in Gaza

(2023)

Open
Other

Şahin-Mencütek, Z., & Meininghaus, E.

Syrian Refugee Returns, Reintegration Experiences and Risks

(2023)

Open
Other

Yildirim-Schlüsing, C., & Meininghaus, E.

Yazidis in Germany: Don’t Deport - Negotiate

(2023)

Open

Events

Thursday, 22nd February, 2024
IN-PERSON

German Return Policy and the German Deportation Regime

Monday, 5th February, 2024
Online

Joint Webinar: Reconsidering EU's Partnership and Cooperation Models on Return and Readmission

Monday, 27th November, 2023
Hybrid

Ukraine: 21 Months of Displacement – What Do We Know So Far?

Friday, 23rd June, 2023
Online

The GAPs project has launched at BICC!

Project Team

Dr Zeynep Şahin-Mencütek

Senior Researcher

show
  • linkedin
  • instagramm
  • orcid

Dr Katja Mielke

Senior Researcher

show
  • linkedin
  • instagramm
  • orcid

Ruth Vollmer

Researcher

show

Dr Lamis Saleh

Senior Researcher

show
  • linkedin
  • instagramm
  • orcid

Daphne Wolf

Student Assistant, GAPS Project

show

Project Partners